
Ah, Watchmen, It's taken forever, but it is here. It is here
and it demands us. It demands our gaze, our minds, and
our hearts. Is it the masterpiece it should have been? No,
but it's pretty damn close. Take heart in knowing that
an extended edition is on the way which may make the
film even better.
Story. Goddamn. What a story. While things have been
cut, and things have been replaced there still exists
a great take on the superhero genre. The means of the
finale is changed, but the effect is the same. The story, like
the production values are generally flawless.
The look of the film is one of its greatest strengths. The
costumes, sets, and all of the spectacles throughout the
film are flawless. Manhattan looks great, and certain scenes
are amongst the greatest in film history. (The Apocalypse Dream
and the building of the Castle on Mars)
The weaker aspects? Well Snyder drops the ball on some shots
primarily by either expanding too much on a scene or coming
up with a new camera angle. The new camera angle replacing
what is the original look from the Graphic Novel. Acting is alright
but I disliked a lot of the stuff from the Nixon actor and Silk Spectre I.
What was there that I disliked? Some of the music used was
ridiculous (99 Luft Balloons didn't fit in that well.) To be honest
I think it would have been fine to just have used the score
by Bates. I hate that Hollis Mason's death is removed, and that
we don't get to know the citizens of New York. Luckily we have
an extended cut coming out so the movie can improve upon what
is already an epic time at the movies.
The ending. It's changed and it doesn't bother me. But I
hated how the "NEW ENERGY! ZOMG" thing was stuffed
down our throats. The squid had more subtlety within the
comic. I did hate how everything just explodes. Explosions
are less horrific than a street filled with bodies and blood as
in the GN. Those panels are wonderful, and It's sad to see
them gone here.
My biggest concern was, well is the Dark Knight better?
Honestly? I'm not sure. Both are neck and neck. Right now
TDK is marginally better than Watchmen. Watchmen has
the advantage of a recut version being released later. So
who knows? Regardless Watchmen is one of these films
which anybody who considers themselves a geek must
watch at least once.
Pros-
Adapts the story fairly faithfully
Main players do a great job with the characters
Stylish and violent
Beautiful production design
Bates' score surprised me
Cons-
Cutting of Certain material
Some acting slip ups
Pacing Issues (too much too quick)
Some strange song choices.
I have much more to say on this film. But for now
I am running on 3 hours of sleep. I was 19 when I saw
Watchmen, and 20 by the end of this review. I would
give Watchmen an A.